Pre-flight checklist
Partial overlap, noted for triage: #101 and #64 touch keyboard remapping, #258 touches custom/macro actions. Neither covers the keycode gap below, and none of the three has an answer on whether the feature is planned. Happy to have this closed as a duplicate if you'd rather answer in those threads.
Problem / motivation
I'm evaluating a move from Solaar to OpenLogi on Ubuntu 24.04 / X11, with an MX Master 3 and an MX Keys S (both Bluetooth-direct). Most of my setup transfers — per-app profiles via WM_CLASS, DPI, SmartShift, Back/Forward/Gesture bindings all work as documented.
Three things I currently rely on have no equivalent in OpenLogi, so I can't complete the migration. Listing them here to ask whether they're on the roadmap.
1. Keyboard key remapping
ButtonId in crates/openlogi-core/src/binding.rs enumerates mouse buttons only. My MX Keys S has seven keys remapped in Solaar — Lock PC, Calculator, Voice Dictation, Emoji Panel, Snipping Tool, Mic Mute, and the App-Contextual-Menu key — and there's no place in the config schema to express any of them. Same for fn-swap and backlight timeout, which Solaar exposes over HID++.
2. Running a command from a binding
Two of my bindings shell out (Solaar's Execute: rule action). The Action enum has no variant for this.
3. Keycode coverage in CustomShortcut
macos_vk_to_linux in crates/openlogi-inject/src/inject/linux.rs maps A–Z, 0–9, punctuation, Tab/Space/Esc/Enter/Backspace, F1–F12, Home/End/PgUp/PgDn/Delete, and the arrows. modifiers_to_keycodes in the same file handles Ctrl, Shift, and Alt, with MOD_CMD folding into KEY_LEFTCTRL.
That leaves these unreachable from a binding:
- Numpad keys — I need
KP_Enter and Ctrl+KP_Enter (RStudio binds these separately from main-row Enter, so Enter isn't a substitute)
- F13–F24 — I need
F16 for a LibreOffice macro
- Print Screen as a bindable key
- Media/system keys such as mic-mute (
MuteVolume covers speaker mute only)
- Super/Meta as a modifier, and left/right modifier distinction
Three of my bindings fail on this: mode-shift button → KP_Enter, middle click → Ctrl+KP_Enter in RStudio, middle click → F16 in LibreOffice.
Proposed solution
No proposal — I'm asking whether these three are planned, and roughly where they sit if so. That determines whether I migrate now, wait, or stay on Solaar.
Alternatives considered
Solaar does all three today; that's the setup I'd be leaving.
Related area(s)
Additional context
Ubuntu 24.04.4 LTS, X11/GNOME, OpenLogi v0.6.21. MX Master 3 (046d:B023, Bluetooth-direct) and MX Keys S (Bluetooth-direct). Source references are at tag v0.6.21.
Pre-flight checklist
Partial overlap, noted for triage: #101 and #64 touch keyboard remapping, #258 touches custom/macro actions. Neither covers the keycode gap below, and none of the three has an answer on whether the feature is planned. Happy to have this closed as a duplicate if you'd rather answer in those threads.
Problem / motivation
I'm evaluating a move from Solaar to OpenLogi on Ubuntu 24.04 / X11, with an MX Master 3 and an MX Keys S (both Bluetooth-direct). Most of my setup transfers — per-app profiles via
WM_CLASS, DPI, SmartShift, Back/Forward/Gesture bindings all work as documented.Three things I currently rely on have no equivalent in OpenLogi, so I can't complete the migration. Listing them here to ask whether they're on the roadmap.
1. Keyboard key remapping
ButtonIdincrates/openlogi-core/src/binding.rsenumerates mouse buttons only. My MX Keys S has seven keys remapped in Solaar — Lock PC, Calculator, Voice Dictation, Emoji Panel, Snipping Tool, Mic Mute, and the App-Contextual-Menu key — and there's no place in the config schema to express any of them. Same for fn-swap and backlight timeout, which Solaar exposes over HID++.2. Running a command from a binding
Two of my bindings shell out (Solaar's
Execute:rule action). TheActionenum has no variant for this.3. Keycode coverage in
CustomShortcutmacos_vk_to_linuxincrates/openlogi-inject/src/inject/linux.rsmaps A–Z, 0–9, punctuation, Tab/Space/Esc/Enter/Backspace, F1–F12, Home/End/PgUp/PgDn/Delete, and the arrows.modifiers_to_keycodesin the same file handles Ctrl, Shift, and Alt, withMOD_CMDfolding intoKEY_LEFTCTRL.That leaves these unreachable from a binding:
KP_EnterandCtrl+KP_Enter(RStudio binds these separately from main-row Enter, soEnterisn't a substitute)F16for a LibreOffice macroMuteVolumecovers speaker mute only)Three of my bindings fail on this: mode-shift button →
KP_Enter, middle click →Ctrl+KP_Enterin RStudio, middle click →F16in LibreOffice.Proposed solution
No proposal — I'm asking whether these three are planned, and roughly where they sit if so. That determines whether I migrate now, wait, or stay on Solaar.
Alternatives considered
Solaar does all three today; that's the setup I'd be leaving.
Related area(s)
Additional context
Ubuntu 24.04.4 LTS, X11/GNOME, OpenLogi v0.6.21. MX Master 3 (
046d:B023, Bluetooth-direct) and MX Keys S (Bluetooth-direct). Source references are at tagv0.6.21.