Skip to content

How best to handle the default (Earth) radius constant #941

@sadielbartholomew

Description

@sadielbartholomew

Throughout the codebase we often perform calculations using a value for the radius of a sphere. This can usually be assumed to be the Earth's because the relevant calculations concern the Earth's surface - but there may also be applications to extra-planetary atmospheres and oceans etc. so when referencing/naming the radius generally we should keep that wider scope in mind so as to not to possibly put off those wanting to do calculations for other planets.

During code review for #910 we decided to have a think about how best to handle the Earth radius default as a value that has a default to sensible precision (we use 6371229.0 meters generally), including as hard-coded at present as:

  • in mixin/fielddomain.py as a float constant (potnetially not ideal as a float as technically that can vary very slightly by floating point precision, as a separate concern);
  • a radius kwarg value default for cf.relative_vorticity.

See thread in #910 (comment) for original discussion points.

Suggestion

I suggest that:

  • we add earth_radius[_value] to the constants module as an integer value 6371229 and import there where necessary. The canonical units for it are already defined there:

    "earth_radius": Units("m"),

    so it is nice to have it close to those as an additional benefit;

  • we change any radius reference to make sure it doesn't reference the 'Earth' in the name explicitly, but take our default Earth radius as default (the average user will be considering the Earth and surely in most cases not need to tweak the value from default precision);

  • for any functions that use the default Earth radius, consult that constant - notably where there's a corresponding keyword argument radius take 'earth' as a string default to mean 'use the default earth value', as we presently do for many methods such as Field.cell_area.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions